A new Politico poll released Wednesday shows a share of President Trump’s own 2024 voters doubt the GOP can hold the White House in 2028, a warning sign for Republicans after a rough midterm cycle.
The survey found that 22% of respondents who backed Trump in 2024 believe Democrats will win the presidency in the next election. Sixty percent said a Republican will win, and 18% were unsure.
Harris voters were far more confident: 87% said they expect Democrats to win.
Overall, nearly twice as many Americans expect a Democrat to win in 2028 as expect a Republican. PF Global conducted the poll from Nov. 7 to 10, days after Democrats won control of both the House and the Senate in the midterms. It surveyed 2,000 respondents and has a margin of error of plus or minus 2 percentage points.
The poll also shows a split inside the Republican coalition over what kind of candidate should carry the party’s banner next.
Nearly 3 in 10 Trump voters said they want a nominee who has not worked in the Trump administration. That figure rises to 46% among Trump voters who do not identify with the MAGA movement. MAGA voters overwhelmingly disagree: 82% want a nominee who did work for Trump.
Some Republicans on Capitol Hill are reportedly looking at Secretary of State Marco Rubio, whom they see as less tied to the midterm losses than Vice President JD Vance.
Others want a clean break. “As much as I like Rubio, and as much as I like Vance, they can’t be our nominee,” said Dan McMaster, chair of the Shiawassee County Republican Party in Michigan.
An anonymous GOP strategist put it bluntly: “You’ve got to have some fresh blood in there.”
The Trump team pushed back on any suggestion that the president’s grip on the party is slipping.
“President Trump remains the unequivocal leader of our party,” said Republican National Committee spokesperson Natalie Baldassarre.
The White House pointed to separate polling showing Trump’s approval at 75% among all Republicans and 93% among MAGA supporters. White House spokesperson Davis Ingle said Trump would “undoubtedly go down as the most successful and consequential president in American history.”
On election night, Trump told Politico that he was not on the ballot and that if he had been, “we would have won it all very easily.”
When asked which qualities they want in the next president, pluralities across the board chose “a fighter.” Among Trump voters, 45% said they want “a conservative” and 39% picked “a fighter.” Among Harris voters, 43% chose “a fighter,” 40% chose “a progressive” and 34% chose “creative.”
Democrats have divisions of their own. Sixty-three percent of progressive Democrats want a progressive president, compared with just 23% of moderates. About half of progressives believe being progressive will help a candidate win in 2028, while only 37% of moderates think being moderate will help.
Both parties appear eager to play offense. Sixty percent of Democrats and 56% of Republicans want their party to compete in every state rather than focus on its base. Democrats point to their recent Senate wins in Kansas and Mississippi, their first in those states in decades, as proof the whole map is in play.

