Mamdani Unveils Plan to Close Rikers Island, Pushing Deadline Back Five Years to 2032

[Photo Credit: By Fotografía oficial de la Presidencia de Colombia - https://www.flickr.com/photos/197399771@N06/54813693354/, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=175883442]

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani unveiled his long-awaited plan Friday to shut down the Rikers Island jail complex. The timeline would push the closure more than five years past the deadline set in city law.

Under the democratic socialist mayor’s roadmap, the city would empty Rikers by the end of 2032 and move detainees to four new borough-based jails in Brooklyn, the Bronx, Queens and Manhattan. The Brooklyn facility would open first, in 2029. The plan also calls for three hospital-based units, and it would turn the island over to climate and sustainability projects.

The legal deadline to close Rikers is Aug. 31, 2027. It was set by the City Council in 2019 under then-Mayor Bill de Blasio. Pushing it back would require the Council to sign off, and the administration says the Council will introduce legislation to update the timeline.

“Our administration is determined to meet our moral and legal obligation to close Rikers Island once and for all,” Mamdani wrote in a letter opening the plan.

“Closing Rikers is essential to building a city that is safer and more just,” he added. “We will get there by building borough-based jails – where human dignity is not an afterthought.”

The plan depends on a sharp drop in the number of people behind bars. Around 6,600 people were held in city jails in early November. Mamdani’s administration wants to shrink that to roughly 4,500, which is about the capacity of the new borough jails combined.

To get there, the city is proposing new diversion and supervised-release programs, more support services and faster court proceedings. The plan also includes $146 million in new investments.

Critics have long questioned whether a smaller jail system can safely handle the city’s detainee population. Republicans and some Democrats have argued that cutting the jail population to fit the new facilities puts public safety at risk.

Mamdani had already signaled the original deadline was slipping. Earlier this year he told reporters that meeting the 2027 goal was “practically impossible,” and he blamed his predecessor, Eric Adams.

Adams initially backed closing Rikers but later questioned the plan publicly. His administration missed key legal milestones tied to the closure.

The future of Rikers was a flashpoint in last year’s mayoral race. Former Gov. Andrew Cuomo called for scrapping the closure plan and rebuilding on the existing site. Republican nominee Curtis Sliwa said he would not allow Rikers to close and wanted its jails renovated. Mamdani backed the Council’s closure plan.

Since taking office in January, Mamdani has taken several steps toward closing the complex. He named Dana Kaplan as the city’s “Close Rikers Czar” in April. In June, he permanently closed the North Infirmary Command and transferred three Rikers facilities out of the Department of Correction’s control.

Rikers, on an island in the East River, has drawn federal scrutiny for years over violence and conditions inside its walls. It remains under the watch of a court-appointed overseer.

[READ MORE: Trump Grants Posthumous Pardon to Pete Rose, Baseball’s Career Hits Leader]