Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, D-N.Y., clashed with acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao on Tuesday at his confirmation hearing before the Senate Armed Services Committee. The two argued over how the Navy has handled suicide attempts by sailors deployed in the Iran war.
Cao has served as acting Navy secretary since April. President Donald Trump has nominated him for the job permanently. Cao is a retired Navy captain who deployed to Iraq, Afghanistan and Somalia.
Much of the hearing focused on the USS Abraham Lincoln strike group, which has been deployed for nearly 11 months. Cao defended the Navy’s handling of eight incidents involving sailors in the strike group.
When Sen. Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., pressed him on the matter, Cao answered: “You see it as eight suicide attempts, I see it as eight suicide mitigations.”
Gillibrand objected to that wording when it was her turn to question him.
“Please don’t call attempted suicide ‘mitigations.’ That is such an insult,” Gillibrand said, raising her voice. “It’s an insult to these men and women who are devoting their lives to the armed services.”
She said a sailor going overboard is “beyond a mitigation.”
Cao has said mental health is one of his “top concerns.” He disputed Gillibrand’s description of one case. He said a sailor who jumped from the aircraft carrier was wearing a life preserver and was trying to get out of the service, not end his life.
“That sailor was not trying to kill himself, he admitted that,” Cao said.
“What was he trying to do, swim to Guam?” Gillibrand shot back.
“He was trying to get out of there,” Cao replied.
The sailor, Nicholas McKelvey, jumped from the USS Abraham Lincoln in August. He told the New York Times last month, “I didn’t want to be there anymore.”
Cao defended his record. “I understand what our sailors and Marines are going through,” he said. Gillibrand was not persuaded. “I think your response is inhumane; I think it’s inadequate,” she told him.
Sen. Mark Kelly, D-Ariz., asked Cao about reports of food shortages. Cao said the destroyer USS Gonzalez had about a week of rations left, but he disputed claims that sailors weren’t getting enough to eat. He compared the complaints to “my kids opening up the refrigerator door and saying, ‘There’s nothing in here.’”
Kelly pointed to reports of major weight loss. “Somebody doesn’t lose 45 pounds just because they don’t like the options,” he said.
Sen. Tammy Duckworth, D-Ill., said she would vote against him. “I cannot vote for you because you’re going to be another yes man,” she said.
Some criticism came from Republicans too. Sen. Mike Rounds, R-S.D., objected to Democrats being shut out of classified defense budget briefings. Cao promised to work with both parties. “National defense is not a partisan issue,” he said.
Cao’s confirmation needs Congress to waive a law that requires former officers to be out of active duty for at least seven years before serving as a civilian service secretary. Cao retired in 2021, so Democrats could block the waiver with a filibuster.
[READ MORE: Senate Republicans Unveil Nearly $1.1 Trillion Defense Spending Bill]

