Democrat Mary Peltola Wins Alaska Senate Race After ‘Decoy Dan’ Controversy

[Photo Credit: By The Alaska Landmine from Anchorage, USA - July 9, 2022 Planned Parenthood rally. Downtown Anchorage, Alaska, CC BY 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=122518447]

Democrat Mary Peltola has defeated incumbent Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan in Alaska, according to a race call by The Associated Press on Tuesday. It was the final Senate race of the midterm cycle, and it was clouded by allegations of dirty tricks.

The win gives Democrats a 56-44 majority in the Senate next year. Peltola is the ninth Democrat to flip a GOP-held Senate seat this cycle, the most Senate seats Democrats have flipped since 1958. She is also the first Democrat elected to the Senate from Alaska since 2008.

The result is a blow for Republicans in a state Trump carried in each of the last three presidential elections, including by 13 points in 2024.

Peltola held Alaska’s lone House seat from September 2022 to January 2025, making her the first Alaska Native to serve in Congress, and lost her 2024 reelection bid by 3 points. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer recruited her to run against Sullivan, a two-term senator and former Alaska attorney general. Sullivan had the backing of Trump and Sen. Lisa Murkowski.

The race was defined by the candidacy of a second Dan Sullivan. Dan J. Sullivan, a retired teacher from Petersburg, ran as an independent with the same name as the Republican incumbent. Republicans dubbed him “Decoy Dan” and accused Democrats of putting him in the race to confuse voters. They fought to keep him off the ballot, but he won a legal fight to stay on it.

He finished with 1.7% of the vote, or 4,760 votes.

The controversy blew up in the final week of the campaign. The New York Times reported, less than a week before the Nov. 3 election, allegations that members of Peltola’s team were involved in recruiting him. Peltola’s campaign has denied any involvement in his run.

Trump called for Peltola to be prosecuted after the report. Before Election Day, the Justice Department, at Trump’s urging, sued Alaska’s Division of Elections in federal court. It asked a judge to block certification of the Senate race if Peltola narrowly won.

Trump also traveled to Alaska to rally for Sullivan and zeroed in on the second Sullivan’s candidacy. “The whole scheme treats all of us Alaskans with disrespect,” Sen. Sullivan said.

On the campaign trail, Sullivan and his allies tied Peltola to “Lower 48 liberals” who want to restrict oil and gas drilling, mining and other resource development, issues central to Alaska’s economy. Peltola ran on affordability.

Counting took nearly two weeks, which is typical in Alaska because of the state’s large number of absentee ballots. As her lead grew, Peltola’s campaign declared there was “no mathematical path” for Sullivan to win.

Peltola’s win closes the book on a brutal cycle for the GOP, with Democrats flipping both chambers of Congress. Questions about the “Decoy Dan” scheme, and the DOJ’s lawsuit, are unlikely to go away anytime soon.

[READ MORE: CNN Reports Iran Developing Plans for Possible ‘Dirty Bomb’ Attack on Senior Trump Officials in Washington]